This study presents findings about the effects of digitization on women’s savings groups from a randomized control trial in Southern Tanzania. The trial was implemented in 2016-17 by the Aga Khan Foundation (AKF), Selcom, and BFA Global. The product tested was a software platform built by AKF and Selcom that allowed group members to save, request loans, make loan payments, and receive loans and share-outs through mobile money. The researchers tracked the savings and loan behaviors of 206 women in 23 savings groups and investigated their skills and attitudes toward mobile technologies. The savings groups were randomly assigned to two groups: control (continue to operate as Cash Savings Groups) or treatment (cashless Digital Savings Groups) (DSGs). 

The study found that DSG members were initially skeptical about using a new digital product. In fact, the novelty and risk aversion drove some group members away, which eroded trust in the groups. DSG members who persevered, however, eventually gained confidence in the platform while many members who dropped out stated that they would re-join for the next DSG cycle. The results indicate that digitization improved the perceived safety of funds, saved members time, and increased members’ comfort using mobile phones and mobile money. Digital learning and improved attitudes towards digital financial services were added benefits, albeit their pace and magnitude were modest. The study concludes that digitizing saving groups appears to create encouraging progress towards closing the digital divide, although expectations that digitization is an easy fix for the digital divide need to be tempered. The study includes a set of recommendations on how additional training and peer learning opportunities could enhance the benefits of the DSG platform.

This study will be useful to organizations interested in implementing and evaluating DSG projects.

Leave a Reply

View all comments

Related Resources

Read
Brief
Digital Transformation Digital Wallet Digitization Benefits Digitization Risks & Barriers
Brief
Digital Transformation Digital Wallet Digitization Benefits Digitization Risks & Barriers

Digital Savings Groups In Uganda – A Learning Brief

U-Learn
2022

Digital Savings Groups In Uganda – A Learning Brief

This learning brief offers critical reflections on whether a savings group in the Uganda refugee response is ready to go digital, on the objectives for pursuing digitisation/digitalisation, and on key challenges in making the shift. The brief was developed by Uganda Learning, Evidence, Accountability, and Research Network (U-Learn) in collaboration with the Uganda Inter-Agency Cash […]
Read
Article
Digital Inclusion Digital Payments Digital Recordkeeping Digital Transformation
Article
Digital Inclusion Digital Payments Digital Recordkeeping Digital Transformation

Reaching Informal Savings Groups with Formal Financial Products: A Study’s Unexpected Findings Reveal the Challenges of Digitizing Transactions

By Raksha Vasudevan
NextBillion
2022

Reaching Informal Savings Groups with Formal Financial Products: A Study’s Unexpected Findings Reveal the Challenges of Digitizing Transactions

This article discusses the main findings from a qualitative assessment of Savings at the Frontier (SatF) projects in Ghana, Tanzania, and Zambia, implemented in 2015-2022 and funded by the Mastercard Foundation. The program sought to bridge the gap between formal financial services and informal savings groups, enabling members to access the financial services that best […]